Hello Dregg fans. If we haven't already figured it out, I am a huge comic book fan. Why am I reminding you? Well, DC just relaunched their entire line of books, starting everything back at #1. And I'm going to review them. That's right folks, I read all 52 of DC's #1's. Now, before we get started, there are some things to be aware of:
-DC didn't start everything over. They call it a "soft reboot", meaning some histories (Batman, Green Lantern, Legion of Super-Heroes) remain largely unaffected.
-This means that some books are a little difficult to get into and not especially "New-Reader Friendly"
-This is MY opinion. There are books that I liked or even loved that others are trashing as garbage, and the other way around. So while my opinion is the only one that matters, you should check them out for yourself.
-I'm going to tell you which books are reader unfriendly (and why) and which books have controversy surrounding them and my stance on it. Politics, Oy.
-This list is split into four categories: 0 (the books I loved), 1 (the books I liked), 2 (the books that I'm indifferent to), and 3 (the books I think are garbage).
Alright! Let's get this show on the road!
0--My Pull List
-the books are in alphabetical order, not in order of preference.
#1-Action Comics: This book is written by Grant Morrison and documenting Superman’s earlier career before he was famous or even liked by the public. This book is great. It has a coherent beginning, middle and end. It has some strong character choices, like Clark being a little tougher on criminals and threatening them in a Batman-esque way. The dialogue between characters is believable and realistic. It has clean, solid art done by Rags Morales that makes the book look as good as it “sounds”.
Why is it on my pull list? Because while some fans are screaming “Not my Supes”, I think this particular revamp on Superman is refreshing and imaginative instead of the bland, “too perfect” Superman we are used to.
Is it new-reader friendly? Of course. This is a brand new chapter in the epic story. While it doesn’t have an origin (very few of the books do), it is still a solid introduction to Clark.
#2-All-Star Western: This book is written by Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray weaving a tale of murder and mystery in Gotham circa 1880’s starring horrifically scarred bounty hunter Jonah Hex. While many of the books in the “New 52” have cliff hanger endings, their effectiveness is wildly varied. In this case, the ending feels like only the beginning of a bigger story without feeling the need to sigh over the wait for the next issue. As a Jonah Hex fan, I’m so glad that he has his own ongoing book again, especially with such lovely art by Moritat. The covers are beautiful, and the internal art is great also. This is He at his finest, and it would be a shame to miss out.
Why is it on my pull list? Because I get tired of reading Cape books. As much as I love seeing a muscular guy in a colorful costume running around punching things saying crappy one-liners, I need something…else. Just like you can’t eat chicken fettuccine all the time, you have to have steak and potatoes, too. I love this book and will continue to support it because not only is Jonah Hex an interesting character, but he’s not your average hero. He’s not funny, or charming, or handsome, or particularly kind, and that’s what’s great about him.
Is it new-reader friendly? Definitely. While this briefly touches on Hex’s origin, doesn’t it make it more interesting not to know?
#3-Animal Man: This book is written by Jeff Lemire carrying on the story of Buddy Baker, aka Animal Man. I loved Grant Morrison’s run on Animal Man from the 90’s and this book is very reminiscent of that. What makes Buddy Baker so different from any other superhero in the DCU is his supporting cast. He is happily married with kids. The story did not discuss Buddy’s powers or his connection to the Red that gives him his powers but set up an ensnaring story that will keep readers coming back. Travel Foreman’s art is stylized in a way that works very well for the book. The black and white pages are so eye catching and wonderfully drawn. The ending revealing dangerous powers his young daughter is developing makes a reader almost feel cheated that the book only has 20 pages.
Why is this book on my Pull List? This book promises to be scary and thrilling. I’ll be sticking around for a while.
Is it new-reader friendly? Not so much. While we do get introduced to Buddy and his wife and kids, it’s the powers that he and his daughter have that the story is about. For the record, this book is not for kids, with its adult themes and graphic imagery.
#4-Aquaman: This book is written by Geoff Johns following the tale of Arthur Curry being “nobody’s favorite superhero”. Aquaman, as everyone knows, had been the butt of every superhero joke since his appearance on Super Friends. This book does something different than every other Aquaman book to my knowledge has. It makes fun of Aquaman. Johns had every citizen and police officer make jokes about Aquaman while Arthur himself is calm and patient with all these douchebags. The art by Ivan Reis is bright and stunning. The flashback pages touching on Arthur’s origin are sweet and touching. The set up for an aquatic villain is brilliantly pulled off. This book is outrageous.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because it’s well-written and presents an interesting take on Aquaman that I’m dying to see more of.
Is it new-reader friendly? Most definitely. You don’t have to know anything about Aquaman or his wife to love this.
#5-Batman: This book is written by Scott Snyder peering into the life of the urban legend Batman. I like this book because it feels like the beginning of something great. Also, Scott Snyder’s previous experience writing Detective Comics is more than enough for me. While this story doesn’t go over any origin material, the story is about what Batman does best: being the world’s greatest detective. Greg Capullo’s clean pencils and inks make Gotham’s lights look bright and the darks look darker. This book is good because the relationships between the characters are intact and the story is interesting.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because I love Scott Snyder’s work, I love Batman and the members of the Bat family and I love good stories. What else?
Is it new-reader friendly? Absolutely not. Unless you’re willing to stick it out and learn about the history of the Robins, Batman’s “death”, Batman Inc., and Damian, this is probably not something to keep picking up.
#6-Batwoman: This book is written J.H. Williams III following the adventures of Kate Kane as the Batwoman. This book is great because Kate Kane’s story is different than the rest of the Bat family, but also the same. She is part of DC’s “push for diversity”. Her story is about a figure called “The Weeping Woman” that kidnaps children and Kate’s determination to find them. This book is special compared to the rest of the 52 because it was supposed to be out months ago, picking up where Greg Rucka’s brief run with Kate on Detective Comics left off. Kate is a special character with a unique origin and a story that is interesting and compelling. This book is only better because of its amazing art by J.H. Williams III with beautiful two page splashes and panel organization.
Why is this book in my Pull List? If not for the story or the characters then the amazing art.
Is it new-reader friendly? Yes and no. While a new reader may be confused about some things concerning Kate’s origin and past, the story is enjoyable as is.
#7-Demon Knights: This book is written by Paul Cornell and opens a doorway to the past to look at the Dark Ages in Europe. This book is about the demon Etrigan and his human host, Jason Blood. This book is great because it is enjoyable for new readers as well as holding Easter eggs for old fans. Sir Ystin, the Shining Knight from Morrison’s Seven Soldiers of Victory will be appearing as well as Madame Xanadu and Vandal Savage. The story will follow the medieval adventures of Etrigan and the mystics of the Dark Ages. Diogenes Venes’ pencils are visually appealing and the colors are clean and solid. I have high hopes that this book continues to impress me as much as the first issue did.
Why is this book on my Pull List? The same reason Jonah Hex is. I get bored of Capes and need something else. Variety inspires creativity and I’m glad that DC is pushing books that aren’t just about Capes.
Is it new-reader friendly? For sure. This book is very easy to jump into and love.
#8-Green Lantern: This book is written by Geoff Johns documenting the life of the Green Lantern of space sector 2814 (the sector containing Earth). This book has some controversy surrounding it. Mostly because of the trouble Geoff Johns went through to bring back Hal Jordan from the dead and what ripples that sent out into the universe. Since Hal has been the primary Lantern since his creation in the 1950’s, it seems that he has acquired a lot of fans and even more haters. But, this book (right now) is not even about Hal Jordan. Another realm of DC mythos that has remained untouched was Green Lantern, this book picking up where the last series ended. This book is good because it is following Sinestro as the Lantern if 2814 instead of Hal, which is an interesting angle. The art in this book is clean, but Doug Mahnke’s work on faces is…odd. Everything is too sharp and to heavily outlined.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because I’m a pre-existing fan and curious about where the story will go from where it is now.
Is it new-reader friendly? Can I laugh? Is that sufficient? All joking aside, Lantern mythos is another book that’s difficult to get into simply because of the complexity of it. And since so much that’s happened to the DCU is Lantern-related. If you’re willing to stick it out or do some research (Wikipedia is fine), then this is definitely worth a pick up.
#9-I, Vampire: This book is written by Joshua Hale Fialkov peering into the life of a vampire named Andrew. This book is one of the biggest surprises of the DC New 52. I personally expected this book to be garbage but was pleasantly surprised. This story is about Andrew’s crazy ex-girlfriend Mary creating a vampire army to go to war against the humans. Andrew wants to stop it from happening. The dialogue and characters are inventive and interesting. The premise is imaginative and surprisingly creative. And much to my surprise, the art by Andrea Sorrentino is perfect for such a dark book. It has heavy inks and dark shadows bringing a sense of darkness and suspense to the book, making the brights seem brighter. The environment is bleak, just like it’s supposed to be. Reading it is like watching a great vampire movie frame by frame.
Why is it on my Pull List? Because I like vampires that aren’t angsty, sparkly stalkers! Seriously though, I, Vampire is interesting, engaging and thrilling, and I can’t wait to see where it goes from here.
Is it new-reader friendly? Definitely. This kind of book has been published before by DC (actually by DC’s “adult” sub-line Vertigo), but never alongside the Capes that dominate the DCU. Pick it up if you want to see some real vampires.
#10-Justice League Dark: This book is written by Peter Milligan going over the formation of the Justice League: Dark, a special team that is equipped to handle mystical threats that regular Capes can’t deal with. This book is great because while it doesn’t go over any origins, it gives a decent introduction to all of the future members: Shade, the Changing Man, Zatanna Zatara, Madame Xanadu, Deadman, and John Constantine and its story. The story surrounds Madame Xanadu’s tarot cards foretelling death caused by the Enchantress’ unpredictable magical powers. I don’t just want to keep getting this book because I’m a fan of the characters—which is true—but I’ll not support a book that has bad writing. Thankfully, this book has a promising start. Mikel Janin’s art is solid, helping the book’s visual appeal.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because I’m a John Constantine fan and when stories about Capes dealing with magic are done right, they’re more than worth the money spent to buy them. I can’t wait to see this team interact with each other, bouncing their personalities and powers off of each other.
Is this new-reader friendly? I’d say yes. While a reader may not be familiar with these characters, it’s still a gripping story and it is only the first issue.
#11-Men of War: This book is written by Ivan Brandon following the grandson of the original Sergeant Rock, Joseph Rock and his military unit’s battle against super villains. This book is great because the stakes given to these soldiers feels real and dangerous. The situation is believable given the circumstances and fairly realistic. The art by Tom Derenick is clean and visually pleasing. I’m glad this book exists, mostly so I can rub its awesomeness in my comic-hating father’s face. I’m proud of this book for taking such a big chance and nailing it. I’m so glad that this book is as great as it is, because if it wasn’t great I’d be forced to pity its inevitable failure. Support Our Troops (by buying this book)!
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because the story and it’s amazing art leaps off the page and into my undying curiosity.
Is it new-reader friendly? For sure. While the first issue was a little slow, it’s got a sturdy start and a strong starring character to build on.
#12-Swamp Thing: This book is written by Scott Snyder peering into the life of the revitalized and newly human Dr. Alec Holland. This book has many Easter eggs for fans of Alan Moore’s original run on Swamp Thing from the late 80’s and early 90’s. Swamp Thing is good because it gives a solid introduction to Alec Holland as a man trying to live his life coming back from the dead without the Green (the force that chooses the Earth elemental that is Swamp Thing). The artwork by Yanick Paquette is heavy on inks, giving the creepy, dark feel that this book is supposed to radiate. The pencils are sharp and detailed, the inks make each panel clear and interesting. The mysterious cliffhanger ending is fantastically pulled off, leaving the reader pining for more. Scott Snyder is an amazing writer and is well-qualified to pick up where Alan Moore left off.
Why is this book in my Pull List? Because the Saga of the Swamp Thing couldn’t possibly be in better hands and I’m curious to see how it all turns out.
Is it new-reader friendly? Yes and no. Similar to Animal Man, without a basic understanding of the Green and the Swamp Thing’s connections to it and his powers, it could be a little difficult to understand. But I have little doubt that Snyder will flesh it out for new readers.
#13-The Flash: This book is written by Francis Manapul documenting the life and times of forensic scientist Barry Allen as the Fastest Man Alive. This book is great because it’s possibly the best introduction in the entire 52. The issue starts with Barry on a date with a co-worker when it’s crashed by criminals. Manapul even gives us readers a quick blurb on Barry’s origin before too much of the story has whizzed by. It has a solid beginning, middle and end and even introduces a supporting cast for Barry (Patty Spivot, his girlfriend, Manuel, an old college friend in hot water, and Iris West, a newshound needing a friend in the Central City PD). Flash fact: Before this book, I was not a huge Flash fan. And I was always a fan of another Flash, not Barry. But with Manapul’s expert storytelling, I’m hooked. Manapul’s ingenious artwork and using every centimeter of space of the page to his advantage, I’ll be Flash fan for a while.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because of Barry. I never thought I’d say it, but I want to read a Flash book because of Barry “Boring” Allen. The story, the science, and the main man himself has me roped in.
Is it new-reader friendly? Definitely. This book is very approachable. Actually, I’d almost argue its old-reader unfriendly. Barry was “killed” in the mid-80’s and brought back a few years ago to find that his world had become convoluted and difficult. His wife, Iris, “died”, went to future and kids (who had kids), came back to the present with her grandson, watched her nephew take up her husband’s legacy, get married and have kids. For Flash fans, it was so hard to see a couple so happy get a “One More Day”, as well as Wally (and his wife and kids) get completely erased from history.
#14-Voodoo: This book is written by Ron Marz and follows a woman called Priscilla Kitaen, a stripper from New Orleans, who’s being followed by government agents who suspects her to be an alien. Now, there’s been a lot of controversy in this reboot concerning sexism and how women are portrayed in comics, and this is one of the books that has gotten the most press about it. Personally, I think this book is very classy and doesn’t exploit the fact the main character is a stripper in the slightest (unlike the other offenders). It also helps that this book has an excellent artist (Sami Basri) and that the story uses the opportunity to portray these strippers as real, honest-to-goodness women with real problems. It also shows the female government agent as being perfectly capable of kicking the cans of four men bigger than her without a hair out of place. This book is great because of its ability to not exploit the opportunities it had and make an enjoyable, captivating story out of it instead. It was a story about an alien dressing up as a stripper, not a story about a stripper that happened to be an alien.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because I’m curious to see what else it can do to impress me (and falsely irritate feminists that didn’t read the book).
Is it new-reader friendly? Yes. As far as I know, this book is brand new, so everyone is getting into it at number one.
#15-Wonder Woman: This book is written by Brian Azzarello and introduces the Amazonian princess Diana. Wonder Woman has a lot of problems in her publication history, mostly because no one writes her consistently and everyone thinks she needs a revamp. This is mostly untrue. Diana is a strong character on her own, without people thinking she needs to be “fresh and hip” every few years/writers. Personally, I was worried about this book when I first heard that Azzarello would be at the helm. I loved his run on Hellblazer, but I’m not a fan of some of his work at all. To Azzarello’s credit, he writes horror extremely well, and that’s what Wonder Woman’s new book is: horror. This book is dark and full of blood and Greek mythology. This book is great because while it doesn’t have much of an introduction to Diana, it is an incredible start to a story and has my curiosity. Cliff Chiang’s art in this book is not particularly my favorite, but it isn’t ugly or bad. It has heavy inks (once again) and good pencils, but to me it just feels a little too pastel. The colors feel washed out to me and everything feels watered down. This, however, will not keep me from enjoying the story.
Why is this book on my Pull List? Because for once, I have a sincere hope that Wonder Woman will be as badass in her own book as she was in the Timm/Dini Justice League cartoon.
Is it new-reader friendly? Yes and no. I was a little confused as to who Zola was, but apparently so was everyone else. I’d recommend it to anyone who wants to read a good story about the Amazing Amazon.
That’s it, Dregg fans! My Pull List! Don’t worry, the rest of the books will follow, just not all in one sitting. Until next time!
No comments:
Post a Comment